Probability, Expected Value, and Everyday Financial Decisions

Most of us use probability in our everyday lives without specifically calling it that.

When making any decision with a potential positive or negative outcome, we consider whether it feels worth the risk. These decisions aren’t always related to the stock markets or assessing the odds at the best new betting sites. For example, we talk about value when making purchases online or in-store

Terms such as risk and expected value are the labels used by professional bettors, traders, and investors to create a framework for these judgments.

The difference is that, in betting and investing, probability is specific, measurable, and at the cutting edge of decisions. In everyday financial life, it tends to be a background process or “feeling” rather than something calculated to the nth degree.

Probability, Insurance, and the Household Budget

Almost every household budget accounts for probability to some degree.

Cars break down. Boilers fail. Laptops die at inconvenient moments. These events feel random, but over time, they are close to inevitable, and we know this.

This is why many of us have an emergency fund or savings account. You may not know when something will go wrong, but probability suggests that something eventually will.

Insurance works in much the same way. On paper, many policies are poor “value” if nothing happens. In practice, they cap the damage when something does.

That trade-off - small, regular costs to avoid catastrophic loss - is expected value in action. Insurance is the price we pay for security. Only the most risk-loving individual accepts the possibility of catastrophe rather than paying an insurance premium.

Odds Aren’t Just for Betting Slips

In simple terms, betting odds reflect the likelihood of an event occurring, a horse winning a race, a football player scoring a goal, etc. Short odds suggest something is likely to happen, but the potential betting returns are low. Long odds offer a higher payout but a significantly greater chance of losing your stake.

Everyday financial decisions follow the same pattern. A plain old savings account offers certainty but limited return. A speculative stock investment offers far more upside, but with a lower chance of success. Neither is inherently right or wrong.

The mistake many people make with betting, investing, and general financial decisions is focusing solely on outcomes. Did it work? Did it pay off? That way of thinking feels logical, but it can be misleading.

Expected Value: The Bit That Actually Matters

Expected value sounds technical, but the concept is intuitive. It asks whether a decision makes sense over time, not whether it works out once.

A bettor placing a single wager can win or lose by chance. A bettor repeatedly backing outcomes where the reward outweighs the risk will, more often than not, come out ahead. Accurately judging expected value over a larger number of wagers/investments is the number one factor that determines whether a bettor/investor wins or loses.

For example, if a stock market investment has a 60% chance of returning £200 and a 40% chance of losing £100, the expected value can be calculated as:

• (0.6 × £200) − (0.4 × £100) = £80

That positive expected value does not guarantee success (40% of the time, you will lose money). However, it confirms that, overall, you can expect the investment to make a profit.

A sensible investment can lose money in the short term. A reckless one may succeed in isolation. That result does not reflect whether the original decision was sound - you might not be run over if you cross the road with your eyes closed, but that doesn’t mean it was a good decision. In the short term, luck matters. In the long term, judgment of expected value prevails.

To take an example from everyday life, you may be able to afford that new car if you use everything in your account and all of your savings. But is a new set of wheels really worth placing yourself on the financial precipice?

Sure, it may feel good for a while, but the long-term expected value of such a decision is almost certainly negative. If even the slightest thing goes wrong, you may be forced to sell the car for a lower price, leaving you worse off than you were to start with. How likely is it that nothing at all will go wrong in the short to medium term? Far better to go for a cheaper model or save up and purchase your dream car when the outlay would represent a lower risk to your overall financial wellbeing.

This type of realistic risk vs reward thinking is essential to making sensible everyday financial decisions.

Applying the Thinking Day to Day

Once you become comfortable with probability-based thinking, it has a habit of creeping into everyday decisions.

Should you lock into a fixed-rate deal or accept short-term volatility? Should spare cash reduce debt or chase higher returns? Should you prioritise security or upside? Should you spread risk by diversifying your income streams or property portfolio?

There are no guaranteed answers, and the right answer can vary according to individual circumstances and risk tolerance. However, an awareness of probability and expected value helps shed light on the decision-making framework, rather than walking through life in the dark.